patching...
Welcome back, Patch Blogger!

Poll: Is First Amendment Speech Relative?

Does anti-gay Westboro Baptist Church deserve the same free speech protections and support as anti-gay Chick-fil-A?

 
0 of 0
A Westboro Baptist Church member pickets. McCarton Ackerman
Photos (1)

Photos

A Westboro Baptist Church member pickets.

While millions of Americans last week were clogging roadways, parking lots, and drive-thru's in a show of solidarity for Chick-fil-A's highly publicized anti-gay marriage stance, another tidbit of notable news managed to get shunted aside.

In a bipartisan vote, Congress passed "The Honoring America’s Veterans and Caring for Camp Lejeune Families Act of 2012," which President Obama has vowed to sign into law. The innocuously titled bill, however, would appear to run counter to the notion of free speech that Chick-fil-A supporters purported to uphold with their presence and their record-breaking business on Aug. 1 as part of Chick-fil-A "Appreciation Day."

The new law would prohibit protesters from picketing military funerals two hours before or after a service. It also would require protestors to be at least 300 feet away from grieving family members.

The measure is targeted at the widely loathed Westboro Baptist Church of Topeka, Kan. The church, led by the Rev. Fred Phelps, has made an ignominious name for itself for picketing military funerals with such signs as, "God Hates Fags," and "Thank God for dead soldiers," saying the deaths are Jehovah's Old Testament-style punishment for "the sin of homosexuality."

The church's funeral pickets, or mere threats to picket, routinely draw outraged citizens of various religious and political persuasions who form human barriers and counter-protests, as was the case when the church recently threatened to picket the funeral of an Upstate soldier. 

"Protests that encroach upon the funerals and burials of our fallen soldiers are repugnant and inappropriate — and they undermine the respect military families and loved ones undeniably deserve," said a statement by retiring Sen. Olympia Snowe, R-Maine, who sponsored the bill's provisions.

So-called "hate speech" can be in-your-face, as is the case with Westboro's vile antics, or it can be veiled, as arguably was the case at this past week's appreciation day, called for by former Arkansas Gov. Mike Huckabee after the firestorm created when the fast-food chain's CEO publicly stated his, his family's, and his company's antipathy towards gay marriage.

While many would argue that equating Westboro with Chick-fil-A is foolish, Christian blogger, Matthew Paul Turner, in a powerful post that went viral the day after the CFA appreciation day, nonetheless argued that the event was a sad day for American Christians, doing nothing to disprove the notion that Christians hate gays and lesbians.

"Christians all over America ignored the second greatest commandment: to love our neighbors. Call yesterday what you want, freedom of speech, a rally behind 'family values,' a sincere fascination with CFA’s brand of fried poultry… but it cannot be called love. It was not love," Turner wrote.

"People felt hate and we ignored that. At the end of the day, regardless of whether or not your Christian understanding of scripture harbors hate or not, a large group of people felt hated," Turner added. "By rallying behind CFA, Christians put an issue above people. And it’s impossible to follow Jesus when issues trump people."

For those who would argue otherwise, it doesn't help matters that Phelps and other key members of Westboro took to Twitter to trumpet and stand behind CFA. (Then again, so did the American Civil Liberties Union).

Bottom line: Even though many of CFA's supporters contended that their actions were driven as much by staunch free speech concerns as any anti-gay sentiment, it begs the question: Despite it's harsh tactics and over-the-top rhetoric, doesn't Westboro deserve the same free-speech protection and support given Chick-fil-A? 

Take our poll, and feel free to expand on your thoughts in the comments section below.

  • Does Westboro Baptist Church deserve the same free-speech protection and support given Chick-fil-A?

    (Voting has been closed for this question)
    • Yes. The First Amendment is absolute and applies to all, even if I disagree. It's hypocritical not to apply the law consistently.
        14 (70%)
    • No. Unlike Chick-fil-A, this isn't protected free speech, it's harassment of private individuals.
        6 (30%)
    Total votes: 20
  • Your vote will only count once. This is not a scientific poll. View Results Vote!
Related Topics: Chick-Fil-A, First Amendment, Free Speech, Gay Marriage, Gays, Westboro Baptist Church, and hate speech

LInda Ensor

12:10 pm on Monday, August 6, 2012

We are in denial of human behavior to think that everyone is ever going to agree on virtually anything. So while I don't support gay marriage, I completely support free speech... including the right of this jerk to stand there with his signs. In a way, I respect him more than all the people who don't make any effort to make their opinions known. Culture, however, is ruled by codes of behavior (or just plain manners) that enable us to get along with each other. The Westbury Church's picketing at military funerals may express their opinions (which they have a right to do), but they TRAMPLE on the rights of people to bury their dead in peace, surely one of the most basic of rights. There are better ways to show disagreement; eating peacefully at Chick-Fil-A was a perfect, CIVILIZED example.

Reply

D. Dantzler

6:57 pm on Monday, August 6, 2012

Even though we, as Americans, can enjoy the freedom of speech, that does not mean that we should shove it down someone's throat. Yes, people have a right to their opinion whether we agree with it or not. But to picket at a funeral is completely distasteful!

Reply
Comment_arrow

william clark

10:01 am on Monday, September 24, 2012

churches are not to be involved in this kind of thing (protesting against something). The job of the church is to preach the great commission, and Christ only gave His established churches that authority, The Good News of salvation through Him , and live daily by His example. We are not to get involved with the things of the world. Christ said that His people are born in this world but are not of it, meaning , the things the world does which is mostly against what Christ taught are not to be lived for or with. There is a great need for Churches to preach against sin and the need for repentance of its members today.

Comment_arrow

stanley seigler

12:20 pm on Monday, September 24, 2012

@william clark
re: ... preach the great commission...live daily by His example.

is this the great commission of the old or new testament...didn't Jesus repudiate much of the old...especially the old-T violence...eg;

He replaced 'an eye for an eye' with turn the other cheek, forgive 70x7, and love yo neighbor...

old-T allowed Israelites to hate their enemies and sometimes command them to slaughter them...Jesus said, “love your enemies and pray for those who persecute you” http://reknew.org/2009/07/jesus-repudiation-of-old-testament-violence-2/

also

raises the question, which version (old/new) should be taken literally...

Robert Kelly

8:32 pm on Monday, August 6, 2012

Freedom of Speech is not absolute! Crying out "Fire!" in a crowded theater is the example frequently given. Libel is not condoned. There are restrictions on abuse, just as there are (or ought to be) restrictions associated with the second amendment for those who are not part of a "well-regulated militia". Could these Westboro Baptist freaks hold up hate signs within 300 feet of the president (past or present) and threaten death? On one hand, society could let them prove how despicable they are, and let them lose their own credibility with time, but that is little consolation to the grieving family and friends of the dead right now. Restrictions are legitimate, just as they are for all the other rights recognized in the Constitution.

Reply
Comment_arrow

william clark

10:09 am on Monday, September 24, 2012

all one needs to do is listen at our President telling people lies day after day.And other people who we elect to serve us and do the job we sent them to washington to do. I have never seen oir heard so much hate and lies coming out of this group ofpeople in washington on all my 75 years of life, as today. Even the Black people of congress in their cacus said they have let obama get away with all his failed policies because he is black,the unemployment rte for blacks is at 14% but not a word to obama about it , the president of their cacus said we would be marching around the white house if that was a white president.(unquote) Its our "pride" that keeps us from calling obama to task over all his failed policies. Folks this is what our country has come to today.....they all need to be fired now, every last one of them .

Comment_arrow

JoSCh

10:15 am on Monday, September 24, 2012

Speaking of hate and lies, how have you been william? I see you're still posting lies without citation, way to accurately represent what we can only assume is the prevailing attitude of the GOP.

If ANY of you reasonable GOP supporters want to counter the lies the most vocal of your "teammates" by all means, here is the forum.

Comment_arrow

stanley seigler

12:59 pm on Monday, September 24, 2012

re: 'Speaking of hate and lies,...'

is the 9th commandment included in the great commission (see above)...just wondering...

Ninth Commandment: Thou shalt not bear false witness against thy neighbour. (Exodus 20:16)

perhaps some BO-hater christian could explain false witness and neighbor...

either they have ref/links (tho not provided) to prove NOT false witness...or dont consider our president their neighbor...oror

are hypocrites...

all of the above, maybe...

Chris McGuire

10:57 pm on Monday, August 6, 2012

Filmmaker takes on Westboro Baptist Church & Homophobia in hilarious new Mockumentary. Laugh! & Please Share! http://youtu.be/V-EVbB4pZ80

Reply

stanley seigler

11:41 pm on Monday, August 6, 2012

re: Does anti-gay Westboro Baptist Church deserve the same free speech protections and support as anti-gay Chick-fil-A?

why does PATCH make it a free speech issue...the issue is: homophobic teachings vs christian 'love thy neighbor' teachings...and specifically: is same sex marriage a right under our constitution...

in discussing same sex marriage...religion should not be used to determine its legality...the US constitution separates church and state...and;

Jesus said, 'render unto Caesar (the state maybe) things that are Caesar's and unto God the things (moral judgement) that are God's.' (something like that)...

in the mean time (until judgement day) as rodney king said, cant we get along'...

there is NO free speech issue...all agree both pro/con same sex marriage have the right (free speech) to express their opines.

Reply
Comment_arrow

D. Dantzler

8:38 am on Tuesday, August 7, 2012

The article was written to inform people about the new law (soon to be implemented) involving picketing of military funerals, for the most part. I agree with you that everyone should just get along, but do not jump on PATCH. They are doing a great job bringing the news to us. And I enjoy reading the responses from people. Sometimes you will see a side of an issue that you may not have thought of before. And yes, it still falls under freedom of speech.

Comment_arrow

Robert Kelly

10:01 am on Tuesday, August 7, 2012

I agree with Stanley that The CFA was not really a free speech "issue". NO ONE said they did not have a right to express themselves! Customers have a right to buy, or not buy, a product based upon whatever criteria they choose, including what the company does with those profits.
Westboro Baptist Church demonstrations are a free speech issue.
The poll is poorly worded. I hate being given a binary choice which requires using some else's words, so I usually don't vote in them.

Comment_arrow

stanley seigler

10:04 am on Tuesday, August 7, 2012

@D. Dantzler: '... do not jump on PATCH. They are doing a great job bringing the news to us [...] And yes, it still falls under freedom of speech.

agree PATCH is doing a great job...sorry if my comment seemed to 'jump on'...not my intent.

re: 'Sometimes you will see a side of an issue that you may not have thought of before'

indeed i do...thanks PATCH and contributors for enlightenment/education...

[...]

opine: free speech is a distraction to pro/con same sex marriage discussion...the obvious right to free speech oft dominates the issue of legal/moral (separation of church/state) re same sex marriage. (apologies for repeat opine)

Comment_arrow

william clark

4:25 pm on Friday, August 24, 2012

stanley: you ought to leave Holy Scripture alone, because you do not understand them at all. The issue is Free speech and the right to give ones personal opinion and the Commands of God concerning such wicked conduct by the sodomite and the lesbian to society. "NO" we all can't get along, not if one is a true believer in God and Christ and is living according to His commands with the help of the Holy Spirit. We aren't to have anything to do with the children of darkness, no fellowship or any other type of agreement with their ways . God condemns the Sodomite and the unbeliever period. And the Christian is to hate what God hates , and the christian is not to condone what the sodomite community does including their sexual lust towards each other.God and Christ says and teaches that these people are "Unclean" and they "Defile " the land on which they walk and live. Christians are not to compromise the truth of God's Word for any reason. Nor are Christians to tolerate what these people do or say . In Holy Scripture . God says that "He hates all workers of Iniquity" And God also said in scripture that "the unbeliever is condemned already" an Unbeliever is one who rejects God's Word on what is sin and evil and wicked, and lives his own way and hates God , and also all Christians who stand against them, and stand for Gods ways by Faith.

Comment_arrow

reg

5:00 pm on Friday, August 24, 2012

This is where your religious beliefs create more division, will. I don't find your interpretations and misquotings of the bible to indicate you know that book very well. God does not hate people, wm. Not any of us. God hates the sin that people commit, but not the people themselves. Go back and read Psalms 5 (where your quote comes from) and re-evaluate it.

Comment_arrow
Patch_comments_icon

Jonathan Allen

6:15 pm on Friday, August 24, 2012

@William Clark:
I'll admit it's been a while since I read all the Gospels, but i don't recall Jesus ever telling anyone to hate anyone else. He said a whole lot about loving each other, turning the other cheek and not judging one another though.

JoSCh

10:18 am on Tuesday, August 7, 2012

Yes, Westboro and Chick-Fil-A's bigotry are equal and both should be protected under the law equally, distasteful or not. Both should be able to donate to whatever hate causes they want, although I do NOT support the tax exempt status of any of these hate groups. In fact I don't really support tax exemptions for any groups.

Reply
Comment_arrow

SDR

10:40 am on Tuesday, August 7, 2012

Let me tell you how it will be,
There’s one for you, nineteen for me,
‘Cause I’m the Taxman,
Yeah, I’m the Taxman.
Should five per cent appear too small,
Be thankful I don’t take it all.
‘Cause I’m the Taxman,
Yeah, I’m the Taxman.

(If you drive a car ), I’ll tax the street,
(If you try to sit ), I’ll tax your seat,
(If you get too cold ), I’ll tax the heat,
(If you take a walk ), I’ll tax your feet.
Taxman.

‘Cause I’m the Taxman,
Yeah, I’m the Taxman.
Don’t ask me what I want it for
(Haha! Mister Wilson!)
If you don’t want to pay some more
(Haha! Mister Heath!),
‘Cause I’m the Taxman,
Yeah, I’m the Taxman.

Now my advice for those who die, (Taxman!)
Declare the pennies on your eyes, (Taxman!)
‘Cause I’m the Taxman,
Yeah, I’m the Taxman.
And you’re working for no-one but me,
(Taxman).

Comment_arrow

JoSCh

10:50 am on Tuesday, August 7, 2012

Now this is the story all about how
My life got flipped, turned upside down
And I'd like to take a minute just sit right there
I'll tell you how I became the prince of a town called Bel-Air

In West Philadelfia born and raised
On the playground where I spent most of my days
Chilling out, maxing, relaxing all cool
And all shooting some b-ball outside of the school
When a couple of guys said "we're up in no good"
Started making trouble in my neighbourhood
I got in one little fight and my mom got scared
And said "you're moving with your aunt and uncle in Bel-Air"

I begged and pleaded with her the other day
But she packed my suitcase and sent me on my way
She gave me a kissin' and she gave me my ticket
I put my walkman on and said I might as well kick it

First class, yo this is bad,
Drinking orange juice out of a champagne glass
Is this what the people of Bel-Air livin' like,
Hmm this might be alright!

I whistled for a cab and when it came near the
Licensplate said "Fresh" and had a dice in the mirror
If anything I could say that this cab was rare
But I thought now forget it, yo home to Bel-Air

I pulled up to a house about seven or eight
And I yelled to the cabby "Yo, home smell you later"
Looked at my kingdom I was finally there
To settle my throne as the prince of Bel-Air

Comment_arrow

william clark

12:44 pm on Monday, September 24, 2012

God's Word is not bigotry as many of you state... Proverbs 6:16, These six things doth the Lord hate: a proud look, a lying tongue,and hands that shed innocent blood, An heart that deviseth wicked imaginations, feet that be swift in running to mischief, A false witness that speaketh lies, and he that soweth discord among brethren. "it must be remembered that all these are within the person as a sin and the Lord just doesn't hate the deed , but also the person that does these things. So , to say God doesn't hate anyone is just not correct within scripture. God hates all who hate HIm. that is why God created hell and the lake of Fire, for those who hate Him and go against His Will. God also hates those who hate and demean His people . You will find many places in the Holy Bible where God uses the word Hate towards man and his sin and iniquity. Both in the Old and New Testament. Many also misquote Christ about Judging one-another, Matt. 7:1 is not a blanket command on not ever Judging others. that tells us how we are to Judge others . Because in John 7:24 Christ commands us to "Judge Righteous Judgment" not to judge according to outward appearance. In other words , we are to use God's Word to Judge all things, not our own opinions. And the other statement used by so many people to justify their sin of homosexuality, is "Love thy neighbor as thyself".....That is speaking about thy brother or sister in Christ not some unbeliever down the street. It is thy neighbor in the faith.

Comment_arrow

reg

12:48 pm on Monday, September 24, 2012

I don't see "God hates fags" in any of those six. And if we're not supposed to use our opinions, then why do so many apply their own opinions of God's word?

Comment_arrow

stanley seigler

1:58 pm on Monday, September 24, 2012

all BO-hater christians should read WC's ref...

'Proverbs 6:16, These six things doth the Lord hate: a proud look, a lying tongue...A false witness that speaketh lies, and he that soweth discord among brethren...'

if BO-haters are not speaking lies and sowing discord, they should provide refs/links to statements they make...

re: ' "Love thy neighbor as thyself".....That is speaking about thy brother or sister in Christ not some unbeliever down the street. It is thy neighbor in the faith.'

review the parable of the good samaritan for interpretation of neighbor...

'Finally, a Samaritan comes by. Samaritans and Jews generally despised each other, but the Samaritan helps the injured man. Jesus is described as telling the parable in response to a question regarding the identity of the "neighbour" which Leviticus 19:18 says should be loved.'
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Parable_of_the_Good_Samaritan

also

But I say to you who hear, love your enemies, do good to those who hate you, (luke 6:27)

are those who mis quote Jesus false teacher...ie,

...false prophets also arose among the people, just as there will be false teachers among you, who will secretly bring in destructive heresies...

eg, 'destructive heresies'

That is speaking about thy brother or sister in Christ not some unbeliever down the street. It is thy neighbor in the faith.

Bill1776

9:29 pm on Tuesday, August 7, 2012

They have a constitutional right to be there rather I agree with them or not.

Reply
Comment_arrow

stanley seigler

11:14 pm on Tuesday, August 7, 2012

@Bill1776: '...a constitutional right to be there...'

gawd find myself in an unbelievable position...agreeing w/ bill1773...OTOH

this might be the equivalent to yelling fire in a theater...depending on the attitudes/tempers of those present...whether it is a peaceful or violent demonstration...

then we cant legislate human nature or cure stupidly...so the right to free speech trumps unacceptable behavior.

Comment_arrow

JoSCh

9:20 am on Wednesday, August 8, 2012

How do you feel about the "ground zero mosque" Bill?

This isn't the equivalent to yelling fire in a theater. Westboro for all their obvious faults are tremendous protesters; they know the law and they know how to use it against those that would protest them. I do wish we could revoke their tax exempt status. People like SDR may support subsidizing hate but it pisses me off.

Comment_arrow

stanley seigler

4:52 pm on Wednesday, August 8, 2012

@JoSCh: '...support subsidizing hate...'

we cant cherry pick groups to which we grantee constitutional free speech rights...those rights are guaranteed to 'the good, the bad, and the ugly'...eg, those 'subsidizing hate'

not that anyone cares (or should care)...but i am more comfortable supporting the ground zero mosque than the westboro un-true baptists.

in any event, wish we could/would address issues vice distractions...the Chick issue is, plain and simply, homophobia...not free speech rights...lets discuss, eg:

*reasons, other than biblical, for homophobia...
*is homosexuality detrimental to society
*maybe related: is pornography detrimental
*is homophobia compatible with christian love...
*who should judge: the Spirit or true baptists
*limits of free speech. yelling fire. what else
*etcetc

Comment_arrow

JoSCh

5:04 pm on Wednesday, August 8, 2012

By "subsidizing hate" I mean granting them tax exempt status. Tax everyone who makes money. I never mentioned or supported suppressing their or anybodies right to free speech, the opposite in fact. Let the racists and hypocrites advertise what they are instead of hiding it.

Comment_arrow

stanley seigler

6:06 pm on Wednesday, August 8, 2012

@JoSCh: '...I mean granting them tax exempt status...'

think i got that...but "subsidizing hate", in my mind, goes much further than tax exemptions...eg, supporting hate by silence...acquiescing to the haters...pandering to the haters to win elections...

to the tax issue:

why current system so complicated...just a percentage of income (all money earned)...perhaps churches/charities could be granted a lower percentage...

Comment_arrow

JoSCh

8:36 pm on Wednesday, August 8, 2012

I agree in principle, but that isn't what subsidized means.

The tax system is so convoluted because it makes it easier to cheat. I agree, progressive individual taxes based on how much you make, something like 3% to 50%, regardless of income source. Quit subsidizing home ownership and families, both are categories I'm in fwiw. Tax business similarly but with a much lower top rate and eliminate write offs. The "cost of doing business" should be borne by the business, not the taxpayer.

Comment_arrow

stanley seigler

10:13 pm on Wednesday, August 8, 2012

@JoSCh: '... that isn't what subsidized means.

i misused 'subsidize' and probably missed your purpose in using it...i was thinking more of aiding, supporting, condoning, the haters...but agree we should NOT 'subsidize' HATE w/ tax breaks...

course i could, as did humpty dumpty's, say: 'When I use a word, it means exactly what I mean it to mean, no more and no less.'

i agree with your tax ideas...and bet many other do as well...lets do it...it could be eased in (eg, eliminate a loophole and decrease a rate) over say 5 years.

BTW and off topic: universal health care is being eased in...which i am all for...

Comment_arrow

william clark

12:52 pm on Monday, September 24, 2012

We ought to obey God rather than man. amen. we must remember that man has in times past used God's Laws of Moral Good to hold man accountable of his deeds in this society, however, now man has crossed over the line and replaced God's Laws for man too mans sinful laws for society, doesn't work and never will work with God or Man . When you remove God's ways from a society there is no more room for Good and what is Normal and Natural, just plain wickedness and iniquity abound.This is what we are seeing today and for our future and Children.

alice bea

12:04 am on Thursday, August 9, 2012

free speech is only a stepping stone which will allow us the opportunity for our opinions on this issue be heard. i dont condone westbro churchs actions. protesting at funerals is inappropriate and they really arent helping our case. currently there is a large majority that catogerizes disagreeing with homosexuality on a moral or biblical level alongside the actions of westbro. cfa is a prim example of why christians are concerned as to how it would affect their lives. the ceo gave an interview for religous media and now the whole nation knows what he said! there are lawsuits all over the country over this issue concerning businesses that dont want to recognize civil unions or marriages. usually the owners feel that if they provided services for such ceremonies they would be giving aide to something they believe is morally wrong and or going against their faith.

Reply
Comment_arrow

stanley seigler

1:35 am on Thursday, August 9, 2012

@alice bea [AB]a: '...they really arent helping our case...'

what is 'our case'...

would AB provide reference to substantiate statements in the post...eg, that a large majority disagrees with homosexuality on a moral or biblical level...and that there are lawsuits all over the country...

re: usually the owners feel that if they provided services for such ceremonies...etc

not sure any owners felt they had to provide services for such ceremonies...assume AB refers to same sex marriage...can AB (anyone) provide anecdotal (or otherwise) evidence...or explain what ceremonies are referenced...

Comment_arrow

JoSCh

8:53 am on Thursday, August 9, 2012

usually the Westboro bigots feel that if they didn't protest military funerals they would be giving aide to something they believe is morally wrong and or going against their faith

If you believe that trampling basic decency and rights for beliefs is ok then you believe that trampling basic decency and rights for beliefs is ok. Embrace Westboro, they're just Christians exercising your beliefs. Hell, they're doing it better than you.

Comment_arrow

william clark

12:58 pm on Monday, September 24, 2012

Society should never condone civil unions or same sex marriage . we are now trying to destroy the church and ones faith and belief to pander to the wicked as God calls them. because man makes a law to give special rights to two men to have sex legally and to give them the same benifits as the normal couple , one man one woman in marriage , shows you how far we have degenerated in such short time. This is how societies destroy themselves in a short time .

Comment_arrow

JoSCh

1:01 pm on Monday, September 24, 2012

If the public acknowledging two peoples love for each other destroys your faith and destroys your church then they probably weren't worthwhile or all that strong to begin with william.

stanley seigler

2:13 pm on Thursday, August 9, 2012

after around 150 years we progressed to segregated education (of course but equal)...then/and to the covert, coded worded, racism of today...and some have replaced Blacks with homosexuals and muslims as the objects of their hate...

CLIP provides the seeds of USA racism...devaluation of 'neighbors' Jesus told us to love; regardless of race, sexual preference, religious beliefs...

[CLIP] In her essay, which was written for a contest, Williams reflected on what [Frederick] Douglass heard his slave master, Mr. Auld, telling his wife after catching her teaching Douglass how to read. “If you teach that nigger (speaking of myself) how to read, there will be no keeping him,” Auld says. “It will forever unfit him to be a slave. He would at once become unmanageable, and of no value to his master.” ... [Click here to read the rest of this story.]

Reply
Comment_arrow

JoSCh

2:18 pm on Thursday, August 9, 2012

I don't think homosexuals and muslims have replaced blacks as the objects of their hate. Augment is the word that most accurately describes it; for the most part they still hate the blacks as much as ever.

william clark

5:49 pm on Saturday, August 11, 2012

The Black civil rights movement was about something far different than the Homosexual agenda to get america to accept their sinful sexual lifestyle as normal and natural and equal to the Ordained institution of Marriage between a Man and a Woman as has been from the beginning . These misguided people who think that having sexual relations with the same sex is somehow marriage and equal to the ordained institution of Marriage between a Man and Woman for the purpose of pro-creating children and building a family, keeping from sexual sin. and having the correct mate for pleasure. two homosexual men . or two lesbian women can't pro-create, they would be committing sin by their sexual relations and also defile the marriage bed.That is why God , Christ, and all Society's condemn it , they were put to death during the old Testament times, However , in the New Covenant of Grace. they have time to "repent" and change , if they will humble themselves before Christ and "repent" and change , Christ is not going to forgive any sodomite who continues in their perverted lifestyle. God has condemned it . Christ has condemned it, Nations have condemned it . in their present condition they defile the land in which they walk on and live in . Regardless what some in society will say they don't see anything wrong with that lifestyle. God has said it is an abomination . and preverted . and evil. God says that those who support them and that wickedness, shall be condemned with them .

Reply

william clark

9:49 am on Monday, August 20, 2012

I do not agree with Mr Phelps protest on anything, As believers in Christ we are not called to stand in the streets and protest against a nation, we are to reprove the sins and tell people the Gospel of salvation and need to repent of our sins. There is no teaching in the Bible about God's people to go and hold signs and protest against others. we are told to preach the gospel of repentence and slavation.I do think mr phelps is carrying his ways to far.

Reply
Comment_arrow

JoSCh

10:04 am on Monday, August 20, 2012

He is preaching the gospel. Your gospel. That he uses signs and protests as his medium makes no difference, it's written and spoken word. There is no teaching in the Bible that people use the TV or radio or internet to spread your message, aren't those legitimate methods to communicate it?

william clark

9:55 am on Monday, August 20, 2012

why aren't the churches preaching and teaching against this sin of homosexuality and adultery and murder and fornication within our society ? where are they ?? where is the discipline within the church body for sins by those people who commit them ? why doesn't the Pastors and Ministers call for the church to bring these ones before the church and punish them according to scripture ? why isn't there exclusion within churches today ?

Reply
Comment_arrow

JoSCh

10:15 am on Monday, August 20, 2012

Why do you put a space between the last letter of a sentence and the punctuation? Why don't you capitalize the first word in a sentence but then go on to capitalize pastor and minister when they clearly aren't proper nouns? The world may never know...

I can answer your last question though, low attendance (read low profits), enlightenment and evolution. Sorry bro, progress happens.

Karen H.

9:17 am on Wednesday, August 22, 2012

Can anybody enlighten me as to why "Christians" so often focus on sexuality, when Jesus didn't talk about it except to tell people not to throw stones at a woman who had been convicted of adultery? (But I may be wrong about that.)

And these so-called "Christians" seems to be against social programs that help the poor. If you look at what Jesus said, it seems that the times he spoke of the poor and helping others who need it much more often than any other topic (but again, not being a scholar and being too lazy to research this, I may be wrong).

They also seem to have no problem with the fact that the US spends more on war than the rest of the world combined. I don't recall the Christ saying it is okay to drop bombs on innocent people because you are angry over murders commited by a small group of fanatics.

This is why I stopped going to church. Never found one which actually cared and acted upon what Jesus actually said.

Reply
Comment_arrow

LInda Ensor

10:46 am on Wednesday, August 22, 2012

Karen, I go to Old Fort Baptist. Every Monday night, the church uses all 4 of its buildings to: serve a meal to whoever comes, then has 2-4 doctors, 1-2 dentists and an optometrist who all volunteer their time; someone giving massages and haircuts, job and financial counselors; plus a clothes closet and food pantry, all staffed by volunteers with donated items. It is a beautiful thing. Many churches either have something similar or volunteer at churches like ours. You are wrong about a lot of what you said, but especially this one.
Americans (and especially Republicans, you can google this easily) are the most giving people in the world. Who shows up first after any disaster? If America is so hated worldwide, why are we the first to get called, and almost always the first to respond? Things to think about!

Comment_arrow

stanley seigler

1:21 pm on Wednesday, August 22, 2012

@Linda Ensor: 'especially Republicans, are the most giving people in the world.'

true of many indivauls and some churches...NOT as a political philosophy promoted by trickle UP, voodoo, political policies...and there are many 'sunday go to meeting' hypocrites which possible lead many karenH'conclusion:

'This is why I stopped going to church. Never found one which actually cared and acted upon what Jesus actually said.' [Karen H]

the scribes/pharisees are still with us...for 2000 yrs, they have not heeded Jesus:

'Woe unto you, scribes and Pharisees, hypocrites! for ye pay tithe of mint and anise and cummin, and have omitted the weightier matters of the law, judgment, mercy, and faith: these ought ye to have done, and not to leave the other undone.' Matthew 23:23-24

'Many Republicans believe theirs is the party of Jesus Christ, but, in practice, they are the party of an atheist, Hollywood intellectual named Ayn Rand...Republicans act as if their approach to government is somehow part of a divine plan, but their philosophy contains very little of Jesus and a lot of Ayn Rand' http://groups.yahoo.com/group/DDRIGHTS/message/8346

Comment_arrow

JoSCh

2:09 pm on Wednesday, August 22, 2012

...Republicans are the most giving people in the world.

It really depends on how you define charity. Republicans tithe more but not all tithing goes to charity, much of it goes to administration costs of the church so your claim is murky at best. Church programs aren't social programs and can't reasonably substitute for them. America isn't "hated" worldwide; most people are indifferent to us and the ones I've talked to admire us.

That said, it's nice that your church is so charitable. Way to go.

Comment_arrow

stanley seigler

6:33 pm on Wednesday, August 22, 2012

re: America isn't "hated" worldwide; most people are indifferent to us and the ones I've talked to admire us

FYI

'Since Barack Obama entered office, the world's view of the United States has 'improved sharply,' according to a poll carried out by the BBC World Service.

Nearly 30,000 people in 28 countries were asked to rate countries on their positive impact upon the world. This year 46% of the respondents rated the US's influence as positive - the first time since 2005 that the survey returned more positive votes than negative for America'
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2010/04/19/worlds-opinion-of-us-has_n_542598.html

Comment_arrow

william clark

4:47 pm on Friday, August 24, 2012

Karen: Christ told the woman caught in adultery. told her to go and sin no more. She did sin in adultery, but the men did also. that is why they all left, Christians are not against programs that help the poor ! the churches are the places that help more of the poor than the Gov. does.But Christ taught that it is not the job of His Church to help the community's poor , the church is to help those within that church first the widow and fatherless children, and to fund the Mission work within the church body. It is the responsibility of the local community to help the poor among them, even though the churches do alot of work concerning the poor .We are to give the Gopsel to all men , the Government and some people try hard to stop this great Commission given by Christ only to His Church. Karen I think you have been deceived in your understanding of the truth of God's Word . Karen Christians don't drop bombs on other people . there are no innocent people who call for your death according to their belief. Christ did teach that one should defend ones Nation against those who would want to take your freedoms away to worship God and Christ, Karen man has brought aLL THE WARS UPON HIMSELF . But God does give the believer the right to defend their faith and Nation . the bombing of the enemy should not make you not to go to Church to worship God , or is that your excuse to justify your own unbelief ?

Comment_arrow

reg

5:14 pm on Friday, August 24, 2012

Linda: the US only now ranks 1st in charitable donations and causes. Previous years, it never got higher than 5th. That's because we have so much more need for charity lately. (Third world countries like Nigeria, Liberia, Lao - they're high ranking in charitable donations, too.) And middle class Americans give up more to charity than upper income (that started after Reagan dropped taxes on upper income - apparently, tax deduction was the only thing those wealthy wanted from the donations; when their taxes dropped and they actually had more to give, they started giving less). Also - as one who's worked as fundraiser for charities, I can tell you first hand, without doubt, 100% fact - Republicans give *less* than others. *MUCH MUCH LESS* in fact. As for first response to disaster - what about our own? Hurricane Katrina, for example - took three days before Bush came, and all he did was fly over. Last Dem pres when there was a major hurricane in New Orleans was there - on the ground - same day - in hip boots walking through the water - helping.

Comment_arrow

stanley seigler

8:07 pm on Friday, August 24, 2012

@william clark: '...She did sin in adultery, but the men did also. that is why they all left...'

re: Can anybody enlighten me as to why "Christians" so often focus on sexuality [karen]

for me not much...hope it helped karen...if any, enlightenment in WC's statement...but moving on;

re: the churches are the places that help more of the poor than the Gov. does. [wc]

you really cant believe this so why make such statement...

"But Christ taught that it is not the job of His Church to help the community's poor"...HE/SHE did!! so how does one get from 'give all to the poor, etc' to Christ taught it not the church's job to help the poor...

if you believe the Bible is to be taken literally then could you, as part of your missionary work, provide the verses which say:

'Christ did teach that one should defend ones Nation against those who would want to take your freedoms away to worship God and Christ'

also would you literally interpret: 'render unto caesar things that are caesar's and unto God things that are God's'

hope this means we can obey (it's not a sin) our constitution and separate church and state...

Comment_arrow

Robert Kelly

8:29 pm on Friday, August 24, 2012

Kaaren has some legitimate questions, and most of the responses made some sense even if some of the facts were a little questionable. However, I cannot make any sense at all out of William Clark's response. Is it just the bizarre punctuation and poorly educated syntax? No, I think it is the poorly educated theology. When did Jesus support war? If no Christians drop bombs, is William stating as fact that Geo W and all the soldiers are not Christian? And even if Jesus had given the go-ahead to wage war in self defense, Iraq and Afghanistan did not attack the USA and were absolutely no threat to our way of life.
What do other countries think of us? I think generally pretty positive, but I was on business trips to Switzerland three times during the Bush years, and the multinational professionals I was working and having dinner with were really critical of the US war against Iraq, which was based upon lies to try to win general approval in this country. George W. Bush was not respected, and even the GOP doesn't want to talk about him now. Too bad for us he pretended to be a born again Christian who sent young
Americans half way around the world to kill the people who live there and destroy their countries. Too bad for us he spent all our money, and then some. It will take a long time to recover from those very bad 8 years.

Comment_arrow

william clark

1:13 pm on Monday, September 24, 2012

Karen, Christ told the woman caught in adultery , "To go and "sin" no more . Christ knew she had sinned and warned her not to do it again . Christ never excused her deed of adulltery, He forgave her at that moment, because all the men who brought her had done the same at some point , and the other question would have been . "Where was the man that was sinning with her in adultery "? he was not brought there either was he , ? Karen society is responsible for the poor among them the Bible even teaches that so did Christ, it is not the Church that is to do that , but it does in most cases. The church is to care for its own members who are widowed and those children who are fatherless because of death.
So you stopped going to church because of that ? sounds like an excuse to justify your unbelief . Its always easy to find an excuse to quit isn't it ?

LInda Ensor

10:25 pm on Friday, August 24, 2012

Reg, you have to be kidding about presidents... how long was it before Obama went to the Gulf? MONTHS. I'll watch Bush's personal compassion against ANYONE's.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Robert Kelly

10:41 pm on Friday, August 24, 2012

Linda, lying to justify sending thousand of young Americans half-way around the world to kill the people who live there and destroy their country...and to have thousands of our own next generation of Americans die in the process for a bogus cause...not compassionate.

Comment_arrow

reg

10:57 pm on Friday, August 24, 2012

Nope, I'm dead serious. While my home was still in 8 feet of water, Bush just flew by.

I assume you're referring to the oil spill in the gulf; you're overlooking that the Coast Guard was on that one from the get-go. You're also overlooking that the private company that caused that fiasco was the one responsible for cleaning it up - which Obama made damn sure they did; when they didn't, he stepped in. (And if he had right from the start, my guess is you'd be complaining about him making taxpayers assume the costs for the mistake of a private company....)

Comment_arrow

martin, bob

1:48 pm on Tuesday, September 11, 2012

Prove that your home was in 8feet of water. No proof, no link, no cred.

Comment_arrow

reg

2:07 pm on Tuesday, September 11, 2012

Would you like to the see the pictures? The insurance papers? The few remnants I was able to salvage? My lawsuit against CoE for its fraudulent construction of the levee that broke one mile due west of my house (it received ample funding for a new levee, then built a rinky-dink one instead of the one that was approved, and pocketed the money it saved)? Or how about the gravesite of the person who died there? Anytime you want to meet, I'll show it to you.

Comment_arrow

martin, bob

2:28 pm on Tuesday, September 11, 2012

You make statement, you make claims, you attack anybody that disagrees with you. Then you demand prove.

Well buddy, you never provide proof of anything you say.

Prove what you say about this or any other matter or SHUT UP.

Comment_arrow

reg

2:41 pm on Tuesday, September 11, 2012

Pardon me? I have consistently offered backup of statements, using valid sources, too. On another thread, I've even offered many, many sources to challenge the statements you've made and never defended.

And, as I've already stated, I do have creditable source to my statements here - actual physical sources. And I'll offer anyone who reads this the opportunity to see the physical evidence, too.

EVERYONE: Provide me with contact information, and we can set up the time and place.

Comment_arrow

martin, bob

2:48 pm on Tuesday, September 11, 2012

@ Reg regarding your public invitation.

I have no desire to meet you anywhere or anytime. Such an invitation is Unwanted and Unwelcome. Furthermore I have no desire to see any of your pictures.

The Patch community requires you to support the things that you say "In Public".

Comment_arrow

JoSCh

2:57 pm on Tuesday, September 11, 2012

You show a degree of cowardice not often seen, particularly on the internet bob. Troll harder. A real troll would have at least said he'd meet reg somewhere and then just not show up.

Comment_arrow

reg

3:04 pm on Tuesday, September 11, 2012

I am supporting it "in public" (and oubluc and publuc, too, as you originally posted). I am publicly offering to provide my physical evidence to the public, as I have publicly announced.

As everyone here knows, what other method could I use to meet your request for proof? I could post links to articles with pictures of flooded homes - anyone can do that, though; that wouldn't be valid. To maintain the validity, then, I offer actual physical evidence.

I find your sudden requests to this old article, in challenge to a statement I made here over two weeks ago, just to be another method of argument. Not a good one, either, since you're apparently resorting to silly requests which you won't even honor when provided with respectful response.

Again, I leave my offer open to anyone.

Comment_arrow

JoSCh

3:10 pm on Tuesday, September 11, 2012

I'm gonna die laughing if at the end of the day his whole troll is just a scam to steal your identity.

martin, bob is actually a displaced Nigerian prince and has $15M US dolars he needs to wire transfer two you bank accounts. Please be making to post a picture of your credeet cards and checks on photobucket for secure transfers.

Comment_arrow

reg

3:18 pm on Tuesday, September 11, 2012

it seems that's exactly why he's asking for that, too, Josch. He wants me to post my insurance papers (with all the personal info, including financial institution data) online; to show my home address online..... this guy's requests have me .... troubled. Add in the fact that he apparently has all day to sit around and post stuff on patches across the country, well....he's ID theft troll, maybe?

Comment_arrow

william clark

1:49 pm on Monday, September 24, 2012

stanley: Give all to the poor was a statement to a man asking Christ how he could follow Christ. Christ told him to sell all that he had and give it to the poor and come and follow Him, of course the man could not sell his property and riches and give it all to the poor , because that was his idol and what he worshipped daily , his riches. so he left and went his way. Those type of people today would do the same as that man . They are called "unbelievers" . W e think because we call ourselves "Christians" that we are true believers in Christ yet we follow and live for the world and do the things of the World, we go to church on sunday , maybe on wednesday night also, we do for others at some point because it makes us feel good about ourselves. We think that God loves us because we take out of our day time to go and set in a church and sing modern day songs with loud music and that it somehow pleases God ! or maybe we think it is Glorfying God ...with our presents. When was the last time you ever heard your Pastor speak to you about your sins against God and your need of Repentance ? or would that offend you ?

william clark

1:04 pm on Tuesday, September 11, 2012

reg: I do believe you are wrong in your opinions concerning what God hates and what He doesn't hate, and yes ! God has commanded His people to hate what he hates . that would include people . let me ask you a question reg !, have you ever noticed who God condemns and places in the lake of fire for their sins if they do not "repent" and change ? God doesn't just thrown the sin in the lake of fire, He places the person with their sin in that lake of fire reserved for satan and his demons.Those who sin against God and do not repent and change , He hates with a Holy hate,. as a matter of fact, God . Hates "all" workers of iniquity. (evil-wicked-unbelievers).in 1 Cor. 6:6-9 God shows us all who will be sent to the lake of fire...

Reply
Comment_arrow

reg

1:26 pm on Tuesday, September 11, 2012

I'm sorry you have that opinion, william. I do not believe that God has commanded us to hate the very creatures that He Himself created and placed upon this Earth.

I also don't believe God "hates," as you insist. God hates sin, yes, but not the sinner.

And no, I've never noticed who God condemns - no living being on this planet ever has. In fact, I regard anyone who makes such claims (to know who God condemns) to be quite distant from God, in some self-illusion of self-deity standing.

I will pray for your forgiveness, William.

Comment_arrow

william clark

1:33 pm on Tuesday, September 11, 2012

and reg, in Psalms 5:5 the Lord says , "the foolish shall not stand in thy sight; Thou hatest all workers of iniquity, and in proverbs 6:16, the Lord also tells us what he hates , all of the following are people and the sins within them, these are the ones who are unrepentant, and will not change before a Just and Holy God. The lord was speaking about us loving one another as Believers in Him. he wasn't speaking of those out in the world, and are worldly and will not accdept the Words of God. We are to have no fellowship with the world and its darkness which are the people and children of satan. I know of no-where in scripture where God has commanded us to love those who are of the world, we are to speak to them of the Gospel of salvation in Christ , When the scripture speaks of "love thy neighbor as thyself. means we are to love our brothers and sisters in christ, these are our neighbor's not the ones of darkness who are of the world and an enemy of Christ , I see so much ignorance of the truth of scripture, mainly because one doesn't want to offend another , and pastor's have bought into this diversity thing which God also hates, be not deceived my friend. God does hate . and God will cast the sinner into the lake of fire along with his sins if they be unrepentant and no change of heart . Many have bought into this "God is Love" gospel, and has no other attributes. First he is Holy, second He is Just and must punish the sinner, thirdly He is Love, but only to His own. Amen

Comment_arrow

william clark

1:59 pm on Monday, September 24, 2012

reg: it is apparent you do not read and study the Holy Bible .God's Word for all men. i gave you one scripture where God has condemned those who will not see the Kingdon of God.. so ! if they will not see the Kingdom of God . then it is very apparent they will be cast into the lake of Fire for their unbelief. 1 Cor. 6:6-9 reg are you one of these listed in that scripture ?

Comment_arrow

reg

2:04 pm on Monday, September 24, 2012

there you go again, wm., demonstrating my argument that God's word - written by men, mind you - is still so subject to consistent variations in interpretations by men. (Were that *not* the case, there wouldn't be so many different Christian churches, now would they?) It appears that you are trying to assume the role of God in your criticism of me, though, wm. Based on that do I ask you to *stop sending me messages*. I have no interest.

Comment_arrow

william clark

2:05 pm on Monday, September 24, 2012

some of us were like that at one time, but ye are washed , but ye are sanctified,but ye are justified in the name of the Lord . amen for that truth. we are now set apart from the rest of the world, yes we are indeed special people of the Lord Now by His Grace. He has chosen some of us to be saved and some not to be saved. that is the way God does His will. He chooses whom He wills > amen.

Comment_arrow

martin, bob

9:11 pm on Monday, September 24, 2012

reg doing that personal message routine again.

Comment_arrow

reg

9:46 pm on Monday, September 24, 2012

to william, my use of "personal messages" was in reference to those on this board. To you, baub, I was referring to your actual personal messages direct to me.

stanley seigler

9:36 pm on Monday, September 24, 2012

re: When was the last time you [stanley] ever heard your Pastor speak to you about your sins against God and your need of Repentance ? or would that offend you ? [william clark]

probably about 50 yrs ago...religious dogmas (sounding brass and tinkling cymbals) of any organized religion and religious zealots turn me off...

i prefer to take Jesus at His WORD...

'...when you pray, go into your room, close the door and pray to your Father, who is unseen. Then your Father, who sees what is done in secret, will reward you.'

josch disagreed with the old saw: 'dont argue with idiots.' he said they should be called on their stupidity.

howsoever william clark is beyond the pale and this is my last response.

i believe at best WC is a biblical 'false prophet'...repeating:
'...false prophets also arose among the people, just as there will be false teachers among you, who will secretly bring in destructive heresies...'

at worst a deranged religious zealot...with no understanding of the scripture he quotes...

Reply

martin, bob

9:56 pm on Monday, September 24, 2012

Anybody got any posts deleted lately?

Reply
Comment_arrow

reg

10:16 pm on Monday, September 24, 2012

I believe yours were, yes.

Comment_arrow

JoSCh

12:11 am on Tuesday, September 25, 2012

Probably not "deleted", but just not posted. I've called you people monsters or posted inflammatory posts designed to make you guys lose your racist minds that haven't been approved. Deal with it.

Kaye Fox

11:12 pm on Monday, September 24, 2012

My Bible says that ALL have sinned and fallen short of the Glory of God. Enough said.

Reply
Comment_arrow

JoSCh

12:10 am on Tuesday, September 25, 2012

God hasn't met william yet.

Leave a comment